Do I really need AIA?

One of the frequently asked questions from those new to AIA or other canonical object based methodologies, is whether AIA is really needed in their specific SOA project.

In short, it depends.

Now, the longer version. AIA provides a robust platform and framework for business process driven, SOA based enterprise application integrations. If your business process already has a pre-built Process Integration Pack (PIP) available from Oracle for your specific enterprise applications, then it is a no-brainer to use the PIP.

For example, if you are implementing the Order to Cash process with Oracle Siebel CRM as the front-end system and Oracle E-Business Suite as the ERP system, then the Siebel CRM Integration Pack for Oracle Order Management: Order to Cash PIP should definitely be on your shopping list.  Even if the exact applications (or versions) are not a perfect fit i.e. say, you want the CRM integration to PeopleSoft or a legacy application, then you can start with the PIP and replace the Application Business Connector Services (ABCS) from the Oracle E-Business Suite to the other application. Compared to a 100% custom development solution, this provides you with all the benefits of a flexible integration framework and will be faster to implement since one end of the PIP has already been developed.

So the question “Do I really need AIA” only has relevance for business process driven SOA integrations for which there are no pre-packaged PIPs i.e. comparing use of AIA Foundation Pack (FP) vs a custom point-to-point development using Fusion Middleware. Now, the Foundation Pack is built on top of Fusion Middleware, so it must be providing value-add on top of it. I like analogies, so let’s take the following example.

Which is the faster, better way to build a plane?


AIA - Building Raw vs with Components

Building Raw vs with Components

I think everyone would agree that having pre-built components, engineered and tested to the specifications of what a plane needs, is a much faster and better way, than to do-it-yourself with basic raw materials, even if you have access to the same tools in both cases. The AIA Foundation Pack provides these pre-built components, that are engineered to the demands of EAI based SOA integrations. It provides the pre-built components such as the Enterprise Business Objects (EBO), the AIA reference architecture and programming model, governance tools (e.g. service repository, integration scenarios) and framework utilities (e.g. error handling, message level testing).

So in the case of an EAI-based SOA integration, the answer is absolutely Yes, you do need AIA!

Now, I know many would argue, “but I am not really building a plane, I just want a one-time, quick, cheap solution, which may never need any enhancements”.  In this case, going the route of direct point to point integration using SOA may suffice, but not without risks.  Once you end up building a passenger train (the cheap, quick solution instead of a plane), which runs on a direct point to point track between SFO and LAX, it becomes next to impossible to later turn it into a plane flying random segments (e.g. NY) with a higher capacity and faster performance. In almost all cases, you would have to re-implement the project to start building a plane.

So the key is to be clear on the business needs and then plan for the right enterprise architecture to implement it. If the business needs a plane, go for AIA. Evaluate the use of native SOA technologies with point to point interfaces, only when it is absolutely clear – at all levels of management – that you are building a train.